What is the best material to use on a roof replacement project on a typical Buchan style home in Seattle / Bellevue area?
There is probably no single answer to this question. A lot depends on the look of the house itself, and of course, what the prevailing neighborhood style is. On some streets, even in affluent Bellevue, for example, every house might have a composite roof. If you replace your roof with a shake or synthetic shake roof, it will definitely stand out. While shake can often look fancier than composite, your house may stand out in a way that might alienate your neighbors. So, the first place I’d start is, take a look at the neighborhood covenants, if there are any.